Homestyle Amish Macaroni Salad

“My 3-year-old literally licked the bowl clean!”

There are some recipes you make once and instantly know they’re going into the permanent rotation.

This is one of those.

I brought this Homestyle Amish Macaroni Salad to the table thinking, Great, this will be perfect for lunches tomorrow. I was already mentally planning my leftovers—maybe tucked into the fridge, maybe eaten straight from the container with a fork.

That didn’t happen.

My 3-year-old loved it so much he licked the bowl clean. Not a bite left. Not even a noodle stuck to the sides. By the time everyone was done, the bowl looked like it had gone through the dishwasher.

I just stood there, half laughing, half stunned, and said,
“Well… guess that answers whether this one’s a keeper.”

It absolutely is.

Why This Amish Macaroni Salad Is Different

This isn’t one of those dry, bland pasta salads that only exists to fill space on a plate.

This one is:

• Creamy, but not heavy
• Slightly sweet, just like classic Amish-style recipes
• Fresh and colorful
• Perfect for potlucks, cookouts, or weeknight dinners

It tastes like something that’s been passed down, tweaked over generations, and served out of big bowls at long tables.

Comfort food—but chilled.

Homestyle Amish Macaroni Salad Recipe

Ingredients

For the salad:

• 2 cups elbow macaroni, cooked and cooled
• 1 cup cherry tomatoes, halved
• ½ cup diced red bell pepper
• ½ cup finely chopped celery
• ¼ cup finely chopped red onion
• 2 tablespoons fresh parsley, chopped (optional, but lovely)

For the dressing:

• ¾ cup mayonnaise
• 2 tablespoons yellow mustard
• 2 tablespoons apple cider vinegar
• 2 tablespoons sugar
• Salt and black pepper, to taste

How to Make It

1. Cook the macaroni according to package directions until just tender.
   Drain well and let it cool completely. (This is important—warm pasta will melt the dressing.)
2. Prep your veggies while the pasta cools. Chop everything small so every bite gets a little bit of everything.
3. Make the dressing in a separate bowl:
   • Whisk together the mayonnaise, mustard, apple cider vinegar, sugar, salt, and pepper until smooth and creamy.
4. Combine everything in a large bowl:
   • Add the cooled macaroni, tomatoes, bell pepper, celery, onion, and parsley.
   • Pour the dressing over the top and gently fold until evenly coated.
5. Taste and adjust.
   • Add a pinch more salt or sugar if needed. Amish-style salads often lean slightly sweet—don’t be afraid of that balance.
6. Chill for at least 1 hour before serving.
   This step makes all the difference. The flavors settle, soften, and come together beautifully.

What It Tastes Like

Creamy and smooth.
A little tangy.
A little sweet.
Fresh crunch from the veggies.

It’s the kind of salad where you keep going back “just for one more bite”—and suddenly realize you’re scraping the bottom of the bowl.

Kids love it. Adults love it. And it somehow disappears faster than you expect every single time.

Helpful Tips from My Kitchen

• Make it ahead: This salad actually tastes better the next day—if it lasts that long.
• Too thick after chilling? Stir in a tablespoon or two of milk to loosen it up.
• Feeding picky eaters? Finely chop the veggies so they blend right in.

Why This One Went Straight Into My Recipe File

Any recipe that gets a toddler this excited—without bribery—is worth saving.

This macaroni salad feels like summer picnics, family gatherings, and simple food made with care. It’s not fancy. It doesn’t need to be. It just works.

And next time? I’m doubling the batch—because I want leftovers, too.